Türk porno yayini yapan http://www.smfairview.com ve http://www.idoproxy.com adli siteler rokettube videolarini da HD kalitede yayinlayacagini acikladi. Ayrica porno indir ozelligiyle de http://www.mysticinca.com adli porno sitesi devreye girdi.
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 27

Thread: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Oct 2013
    Location
    New Jersey, USA
    Posts
    168

    Default Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    This person could be a politician or general, or anyone with any significance for that matter. I'm going to cast my vote for Charles de Gaulle. I will give him credit for probably being the one most responsible for saving France by going to Britain in 1940 and rallying the French people, and by keeping French interests prominent with the Allied High Command at the strategy table. But he was not a likable personality. He was stubborn and inflexible, and he refused to place himself in a second tier position when he was fortunate to even be at the same table with FDR, Churchill, and the other great generals of the time. What is your opinion? Was it Rommel, Bradley, MacArthur, Monty, or someone else?

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	degaulle.jpg 
Views:	199 
Size:	113.3 KB 
ID:	7717

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Pennsylvania, USA
    Posts
    249

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    General Douglas Macarthur hands down! He should have been court-martialed for his failure on December 8th, and he was lucky he got the order to leave the Philippines from FDR. It was downright shameful that he refused to concur to give General Wainwright the Medal of Honor, and his strutting about as dictator of Japan was despicable. While his Inchon plan was ingenious, he finally got what he deserved at the hands of President Truman who dismissed him for insubordination during the Korean War.
    Last edited by Laconia; 07-09-2016 at 10:01 PM.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Buffalo, New York
    Posts
    7,404

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    Quote Originally Posted by Laconia View Post
    General Douglas Macarthur hands down! He should have been court-martialed for his failure on December 8th, and he was lucky he got the order to leave the Philippines from FDR. It was downright shameful that he refused to concur to give General Wainwright the Medal of Honor, and his strutting about as dictator of Japan was despicable. While his Inchon plan was ingenious, he finally got what he deserved at the hands of President Truman who dismissed him for insubordination during the Korean War.
    I'm not a Mac fan either, but I think he handled the Japanese occupation rather well if imperfectly...

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Up in the land of the Yoopers.
    Posts
    4,304

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    Though he was not in strict terms military, he was an overrated Personality,(Aside from being Britain's leading Traitor) so i'll put up William Joyce, known to the Allies as "Lord Haw Haw" Male counterpart of Axis Sally. From his image, it looks like someone had set about giving him a "Glasgow smile"
    Attached Thumbnails Attached Thumbnails Click image for larger version. 

Name:	William_Joyce_politician-426x625.jpg 
Views:	69 
Size:	43.7 KB 
ID:	7718  
    Last edited by tankgeezer; 07-10-2016 at 10:36 AM.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Oct 2013
    Location
    New Jersey, USA
    Posts
    168

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    Quote Originally Posted by Nickdfresh View Post
    I'm not a Mac fan either, but I think he handled the Japanese occupation rather well if imperfectly...
    I agree. His handling of the Japanese Occupation was probably his best accomplishment. I'm not too wild about anything else he did.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Oct 2013
    Location
    New Jersey, USA
    Posts
    168

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    Quote Originally Posted by tankgeezer View Post
    Though he was not in strict terms military, he was an overrated Personality,(Aside from being Britain's leading Traitor) so i'll put up William Joyce, known to the Allies as "Lord Haw Haw" Male counterpart of Axis Sally. From his image, it looks like someone had set about giving him a "Glasgow smile"
    I like your choice.

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Pennsylvania, USA
    Posts
    249

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    Quote Originally Posted by tankgeezer View Post
    Though he was not in strict terms military, he was an overrated Personality,(Aside from being Britain's leading Traitor) so i'll put up William Joyce, known to the Allies as "Lord Haw Haw" Male counterpart of Axis Sally. From his image, it looks like someone had set about giving him a "Glasgow smile"
    Any of those propaganda meisters were simply laughed at by the troops. They were a waste of time and money, though I heard they played good music.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Buffalo, New York
    Posts
    7,404

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    Quote Originally Posted by Laconia View Post
    Any of those propaganda meisters were simply laughed at by the troops. They were a waste of time and money, though I heard they played good music.
    There was probably a chance they demoralized some, especially Axis Sally with her "What's your wife doing tonight?" sorts of taunts. But there is no question they also entertained Allied troops with the music and probably did them more good than harm...

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Up in the land of the Yoopers.
    Posts
    4,304

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    Well, the music, and the folksy talking to the neighbor sort of way they worked was intended to insinuate at a subtle level, the impressions the Axis desired to implant. Somewhat like hypnosis, music causes people to drift off a bit, get comfortable, and the little, subtle bits of propaganda seep into the subconscious. It's not always the coarser, overt nonsense that is intended to be absorbed by the listener, but could leave an impression if the listener was in the correct frame of mind. Tone,and cadence of the speaker was also meant to assist in the process, and assuring trustable voice helps the BS go down. Think of Morgan Freeman doing such work, people love his voice, and will genuinely listen to him no matter what he might say. All very tricky stuff, and it does work after a fashion.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Dublin, Ireland
    Posts
    778

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    William Joyce - an odd fish. Born in New York of an Irish father, he spent much of his childhood/adolescence in Ireland (Free State), later going to the UK and obtaining a UK passport. In spite of his somewhat disrupted education, he obtained a First Class Honours from the University of London. By that time, he had moved into the fringes of the British extreme Right. He obtained the notable scar in less-than-Heidelberg fashion in a brawl with Left-wing enemies attempting to disrupt a political meeting called by a right-wing Conservative politician in the early-1920s, at which time he was loosely associated with a number of far-Right movements, including the Conservative right and the British Fascisti. Even early on, he was noted as a powerful orator and an extreme (British) Nationalist and anti-Semite.

    His curious combination of orator and thug was repeated in his association with the British Union of Fascists in the 1930s. He subsequently decamped to Germany in fear of being detained at the behest of the British security services, and more-or-less stumbled into propaganda broadcasting, eventually taking the star role as a propaganda broadcaster on the German radio service's English language "services". Whether his diatribes were effective as used against the Britishis debatable. Exposed to this sort of verbal propaganda, it seems to me that most Brits are more inclined to stiffen their lips, laughing at the same time, rather than falling into panic.

    His eventual fate has a certain horrible interest from a legal point. There were a number of aspects of his complicated nationality (US, Irish, UK, German from 1940) that might have been pleaded in his defence in his trial for High Treason. The one chosen, however, was a technical defence to the effect that the fact that he held a British passport did not in itself imply eligibility for protection by the British consular service when abroad, in particular, when his assumption of German citizenship in 1940 constituted a renunciation of British legal nationality. The British Director of Public Prosecutions argued, in reply, that the fact that his last renewal of his British passport, still valid for at least a part of his time as "Lord Haw-Haw", exposed him to the rights and obligations of a British citizen, even if he was located abroad and had taken out citizenship of his host country - another technical, and somewhat dubious proposition. The fact that his legal entitlement to a British passport in the first place (he had claimed in applying for his original UK passport that he was British-born, a patent untruth) does not seem to have been regarded as significant. Joyce was convicted of High Treason, and his appeal was rejected by the higher courts. He was consequently sentenced to death and hanged. Perhaps he should have attempted the defence of US - or even Irish - citizenship. However, these options, no doubt, were ruled out by his ideological stances.

    As an influence on the war, well, it seems to me that he was mainly a source of amusement to his British listeners. If anything, his broadcasts would appear to have been counterproductive from a German viewpoint. Yours from the Rundfunk Bunker, JR.
    Last edited by JR*; 07-13-2016 at 09:25 AM.

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    9,275

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    Quote Originally Posted by Laconia View Post
    General Douglas Macarthur hands down! He should have been court-martialed for his failure on December 8th
    Perhaps, but by which country?

    Leaving aside the technical status of the Philippines at the time as effectively an American possession on the way to independence around 1946, was MacArthur a greater disgrace to the Philippines, which employed him at great cost to defend it (and from which he departed with a lot of loot) or to the US, to which he reverted as a commander shortly before the war?

    I'd argue that he failed the Philippines the most by failing to live up to his assurances that he had prepared it well to defend itself in the years leading up to the war, and failed the US not much less by his equally confident but baseless assurances to the same effect in the immediate pre-war period. That makes him perhaps the only Allied, or any, commander of a nation to fail completely both nations he served and assured he could defend successfully in the lead up to WWII, and to lose one of them to the enemy, solely by his own spectacular hubris and incompetence.

    Conversely, once he had overcome his failure and the panic that his undeserved career was over, and engaged in his usual machinations to conceal his incompetence in the early phases of the SWPA 1942-43, he grew into the role of a theatre commander and did reasonably well as he gained masssive logistical and other support and notably directly and indirectly from the USN throughout his campaigns and especially from the Australian land forces which with his boundless and unreasoning contempt fought most of his land war in 1942-43. His greatest achievement was, however, creating and expanding a massively successful personal propaganda machine run by a sorry bunch of senior "yes men" who persuaded the public and many in US and Australian government that MacArthur was the greatest military genius in the history of the world and the sole repository of Western knowledge about Japan and its Emperor, presumably gained from close association with the unrelated people, cultures and government of the Philippines.

    MacArthur was in historical terms undoubtedly "a great man" of his time but, viewed against his many "great man" contemporaries, he was as a commander and especially a civilian political aspirant to the US Presidency eventually gained by Eisenhower, whom he described as "the best clerk I ever had", just an "also ran". This is amply demonstrated by his failed and ham-fisted 1944 tilt at the Presidency, which is outstanding for the obsequiousness of his attempts to curry favour with people he thought might help him win office.
    Last edited by Rising Sun*; 07-13-2016 at 10:18 AM.
    ..
    A rational army would run away.
    Montesquieu

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    9,275

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    Outstanding candidate for the most overrated, especially given the mythology surrounding the supposed Desert Fox, is Rommel.

    Panicked and stopped in the approach to Dunkirk.

    Lost in North Africa.

    Lost on the Western Front.

    Committed suicide.

    Subsequently admired by many, who obviously know nothing about his achievements or lack of them, as a military genius.
    ..
    A rational army would run away.
    Montesquieu

  13. #13
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Dublin, Ireland
    Posts
    778

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    Yes, a strong case for Rommel, in spite of the "legend". Rommel's conduct in the first phase of the Battle of France was, when you look at it, extraordinarily reckless. Some of his professional colleagues thought he was mad. Perhaps not mad - but his command of the 7th Panzer was in many ways better suited to a company, rather than a divisional commander. One might ask why, since his deficiencies as a senior commander were recognized by so many of his fellow generals ? Why did they not transfer him to less sensitive commands, rather than more ?

    The answer, almost certainly, lay in his personal connections with the senior Nazi leadership - something seldom if ever mentioned in the construction of his postwar "legend". Rommel had the good fortune, in the immediate prewar period and extending through the Polish campaign, to be placed in command of the Fuhrer's personal Army escort/bodyguard. This placed him in close official and social connection with Hitler and the top level of Nazi politicians. As a First World War hero (EK I, Pour le Merité) he clearly impressed Hitler and others of his coterie with whom he developed cordial relations (at the very least). He particularly impressed Joseph Goebbels, who became his political patron and friend. (Prior to the Western campaign he presented a Leica camera to Rommel, which the latter used to document the campaign in photos). Combined with his talent for self-publicity, these political connections served Rommel well in promoting and protecting his career. For example, his appointment to the command of 7th Panzer Division was less than obvious, given his well-deserved reputation as an infantry tactician and general lack of interest in mechanized warfare in the prewar period. While the process remains somewhat obscure, his appointment to this command definitely owed much to the favouor in which he stood with Hitler and Goebbels. Postwar, members of his immediate family expressed the belief that, without his political influence, he would have been appointed to a Mountain Division rather than high-profile, better-than-average Panzer Division.

    And so it went on. Rommel retained the confidence of Hitler and Goebbels right up to the July Plot in 1944 (in which, in reality and contrary to the legend, his involvement was marginal at most). There is a possible irony in the fact that his ultimate fall to Hitler's post-Plot paranoia may have owed something to the failure of his Army colleagues to defend them. The most obvious example was the behavior of Gerd von Runstedt, his former commander in the 1940 Western Campaign and subsequently in the Western command preparing for the Allied invasion of Western Europe. Even to the end, he seems to have retained some credit with his former Nazi friends, as somewhat ambivalent comments in Goebbels' diary suggest. One might suggest that his previous choices of political means to his career development deprived him of much chance that, when the Devil turned, he might receive sufficient protection from sources that might conceivably have saved him. Also, it calls to mind the admonition of the Earl of Strafford, back in the early 17th century - "Put not your trust in princes". Yours from the Big Black Block, JR.

  14. #14
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Dublin, Ireland
    Posts
    778

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    By the way ... sorry that imi is leaving. All the best to him. But, really, some of his recent posts have been hard to defend, whether on grounds of historical argument or of, I suppose, taste. Best regards, JR.

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    9,275

    Default Re: Who was the most overrated personality of WW2?

    Quote Originally Posted by JR* View Post
    By the way ... sorry that imi is leaving. All the best to him. But, really, some of his recent posts have been hard to defend ....
    And much, much harder to understand for those of us accustomed to rational analysis of historical evidence.
    ..
    A rational army would run away.
    Montesquieu

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •