Stalingrad

[FW-190 Pilot]

I like this movie a lot because most of the movies are on the allies perspective, this movie is kind of refreshing. Plus because german is on the evil side, it is good because you dont know the director would choose a good ending or bad ending for the german, which makes the story unpredictable. Although it is only a 20 million dollars budget, they manage to have good sound and video effect, especially the tank fight and the war in the beginning scene is just perfect and exactly what i want. the only flaw is the ending, it seems to be a little strange

in the total of five stars, i give it 4 stars out of 5 stars

[Gen. Sandworm]

Im not going to vote coz i havent seen it all but the parts I did see looked really good. So if i were going to I would at least give it "Its okay"

[Cactus]

I liked it. Long but good. :D

[Kurt Panzer Meyer]

I loved this (need to get it on DVD).

Some of those action scenes are really chaotic and quite confronting. It seems accurate enough (to my own perception of course).

With regards to the ending, it left me with a "What the..?" as well. But in hindsight, I reckon it resembles the haziness of Apocalypse Now's ending.

[Firefly]

I loved this movie.

A fantastic look at life on the other side and the whole futile buisness of war. The ending is perfect too, very downbeat and definately not rosy.

Three thumbs up....

[FluffyBunnyGB]

Attack! Attack! Always Attack!

My mates are sick of me shouting this at the mighty Sheffield Wednesday from the Kop when we are playing poorly (most weeks then . . . )

[Twitch1]

A worthwhile movie from a different point of view.

[Hosenfield]

is this the 1993 movie you've been talking about?

Its just an OK movie to me. I felt the characterization was too sterotypical and boring, with average acting. The action scenes are a bit dated, and the villian is incredible stereotypical. However, the movie depicts the chaos that erruptted among the 6th army as the high command pulled out with the officers and specialists (sturmpioneer combat enjineers) and left the regular line infantry to die.

[Kurt Panzer Meyer]

@Hosenfield

The 2nd half is filled with too much German self-angst. Self-guilt and self-hate is all too much prevalent. But still, it is an excellent movie.

[Mechanized Warfare]

I saw this movie about 2 years ago and I liked it as well. The thing about this movie that really made it awesome was that you saw the Germans point of view. Despite what a lot of people thought about the Germans, most Germans werent evil war mongers that wanted to rape and pilage. Most wanted to just get the invasion of the USSR overwith as fast as they can and then go back home. They were just doing their jobs like every soldier is supposed to. The Wehrmatch Army were however fanatical war mongers, but thats a different story altogether. :P Anyhow back to the movie, it was done very well, and I loved it. Ive been meaning to get my hands on a copy of Das Boot, which was made by the same people that made Stalingrad.

[Kurt Panzer Meyer]

I think you mean elements of the W-SS were fanatical? Most German soldiers were part of the Wehrmacht.

[Mechanized Warfare]

I think you mean elements of the W-SS were fanatical? Most German soldiers were part of the Wehrmacht.

I always thought that there was the regular German Army and then there was the Wehrmacht Army..........kind of like the regular U.S. Army and the U.S.M.C. If im mistaken then Ill slap myself on the wrist for being incompetent in WWII knowledge. Anyhow Stalingrad was a great movie. :P

[Hosenfield]

wrong. the Wehrmacht of World War 2 was comprised of the army (das Heer), the navy (die Kriegsmarine), the air force (die Luftwaffe).

The german army (heer) and the Waffen-SS(technically not part of the Wermarct) were ground forces.

The Waffen-SS is probably what you are thinking about. They were slightly better then Heer in average combat ability and have very excellent elite units mixed in with above average and below average units.

[FW-190 Pilot]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TPQ9iOzXn9k&search=ww2

preview of stalingrad

[Tsolias]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TPQ9iOzXn9k&search=ww2

preview of stalingrad

Dam I must get this dvd!

[Digger]

Very under rated movie. I talked some years ago to an ex Eastern Front vet, who suffered a long depression after seeing Stalingrad. Though he did not fight at Stalingrad it awakened many nightmares for him.

Regards Digger.

[GermanSoldier]

I can not find this at the movie store. So I might just have to get it from a website.

[Wolfgang Von Gottberg]

I think you mean elements of the W-SS were fanatical? Most German soldiers were part of the Wehrmacht.

Agreed. You would think the 'Princaple of the Master Race' would have only 'Pure Germans', but by the end of the war the Waffen-SS was almost totally made up of foreign recruits.

[GermanSoldier]

I have just saw a five minute part of the movie. It looks like a good movie. I need to get my hands on it.

[GermanSoldier]

Here is a quick look at Stalingrad the movie.
http://.youtube.com/watch?v=OKXDxZ2zFOI&NR
There is no english sub titles.
SO ENJOY!

[Gracie]

Is this movie in English? Or is it subtitled? I had heard it was not in English but I did want to see it.

[FW-190 Pilot]

Is this movie in English? Or is it subtitled? I had heard it was not in English but I did want to see it.
well, i watched it in a friends house, the movie is in another language, but we have the option to listen to English instead. so obviously we choose that option.

[Moreheaddriller]

awesome movie just simply because its seen from a german view

[Koen]

It's not the greatest movie I've seen but it's one of the best and realistic WWII movies I've seen.

No special effects giving you a Star Wars feeling, no heroism making you searching for Tom Cruise...no, a dirty, negative look at a dirty thing called War...

Would it been better with a larger budget? Not necessarily.
Would it been better with real moviestars in it? Not at all!

This one should be in your collection!

[PA.Dutchman]

The ending was an actually remake of a photo of the end of the Battle of Stalingrad found in some history's of the Battle of Stalingrad.

I am guessing they figured if you had an interest in the subject matter you had some previous knowledge of the subject and the battle.

When you see the actual photo you can only guess what the snow is covering, in the movie they gave us an idea of what was laying under that snow drift.

That stock pile of food and drink they stumbled on to was true too. There are always good officers and bad ones. Some bad selfish officers had stock piled this for themselves.

In the meantime some of the populace began eating human flesh it had gotten so bad. It was not suppose to happen, but it was a very bad time to be hungry and no worse place to be hungry.